Difference between revisions of "Method Mix"

From Competendo - Digital Toolbox
Jump to: navigation, search
(Also interesting:)
m
 
(84 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
__NOTOC__
 
__NOTOC__
<div class=teaser-text>Learning styles are different and when using methods, that address different senses or ways of expression we may have a bigger impact on the learning outcome of our participants. The challenge is that everybody feels attracted, although not all share the same bias concerning methods. Therefore we advocate for a mix of different methods. Beyond personal preferences creative and diversified learning arrangements that address different senses stimulate participants' motivation. </div>
+
<div class=teaser-text>Learning preferences vary. Methods that offer variety and provide opportunities for all in the way they are delivered support inspiring and rewarding learning experiences. A good mix and variety also responds to the different phases and dynamics of a learning process.</div>
 
<div class=methodpage-content>
 
<div class=methodpage-content>
==Addressing Transversal Competencies==
+
<div class=left-box>
Basically, we need to make sure that the outcome of our teaching is more than just knowledge, and includes building skills and attitudes. Our
+
===Check: Addressing Transversal Competences===
methods need to be appropriate for the development of such competencies as the sum of skills, knowledge, and attitudes. When looking over your learning schedule, check, to what extent all fields of key competencies are reflected:
+
Methods need to be appropriate for the development of knowledge, skills and attitudes. Check, to what extent the fields of key competences are addressed:
  
<table>
+
 
<tr>
+
====Task-specific factual compe&shy;tence====
<td style="width: 30%;">
+
Do your methods help your participants to:  
===Task-specific factual compe&shy;tence===
+
 
</td>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Identify adequate, knowledge-based solutions for tasks and problems?
<td>
+
 
Do your methods help your participants to: Identify adequate, knowledge-based solutions for tasks and problems?
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Expertise in the specific field or topic of your training...
*Expertise in the specific field or topic of your training...
+
 
*...and how it relates systematically within its field and to other fields
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> ...and how it relates systematically within its field and to other fields
</td>
+
 
</tr>
+
 
<tr>
+
====Methodo&shy;logical compe&shy;tence====
<td>
 
===Methodo&shy;logical compe&shy;tence===
 
</td>
 
<td>
 
 
Are you offering adequate opportunities for training and conscious, goal-oriented action?
 
Are you offering adequate opportunities for training and conscious, goal-oriented action?
* Practicing choosing methodologies and evaluating outcomes.
+
 
* Experiential learning
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i>  Choosing and implementing methodologies and tools on a justified basis.
</td>
+
 
</tr>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Experience with different approaches toward a goal or problem.
<tr>
+
 
<td>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Experiential learning in real challenges
===Social compe&shy;tence===
+
 
</td>
+
 
<td>
+
 
How might your participants consciously experience their relationshipwith other people and actively experiment in shaping their social relationships?
+
====Social compe&shy;tence====
* Cooperation and teamwork
+
Can your participants consciously experience their relationship with other people?
* Reflecting on different interests, needs, and tensions.
+
 
* Team and conflict management skills.
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i>  Cooperation and teamwork
</td>
+
 
</tr>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Constructively dealing with diversity, difference or conflict.
<tr>
+
 
<td>
+
 
===Personal compe&shy;tence===
+
 
</td>
+
====Personal compe&shy;tence/Learning to Learn====
<td>
 
 
Do you leave enough space for your participants to act autonomously,in a self-organized and reflective way?
 
Do you leave enough space for your participants to act autonomously,in a self-organized and reflective way?
* Addressing responsibility, appreciating existing competencies in your participants
+
 
* Training participants to observe and evaluate requirements or options.
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i>  Addressing learners' self-responsibility and their active involvement of existing competences
* Reflecting on how a participant assumes responsibility and approaches self-directed learning.
+
 
</td>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i>  Training reflection and assessment skills in regard to own experience, action or opportunities.
</tr>
+
 
</table>
+
<i class="fas fa-check"></i> Adressing self-organization and learning-to-learn.
 +
</div>
  
 
==Balancing Diverse Needs==
 
==Balancing Diverse Needs==
A variety of methods in your training can correspond to the diverse needs of your target group. The challenge is to get the attention of all your participants, despite their differing needs and preferences concerning the methods. This is less a question of what kind of competencies are being addressed than of preferred learning styles and ways of incorporating knowledge. Recognizing people’s diversity we advocate for a balance - creative and diversified learning arrangements that address different senses and stimulate participants’ motivation. For example:
+
A variety of methods in your training can correspond to the diverse needs of your target group. The challenge is to get the attention of all your participants, despite their differing and shifting needs and preferences concerning the methods. Creative and diversified learning arrangements address different senses and stimulate participants’ motivation and attention. For example:
<table>
+
<div class=left-box>
<tr>
+
===Balance===
<tr>
+
[[File:Methodbalance.png | 400px |center]]
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
+
 
activity - cognition  
+
<div style="text-align:center;">
</td>
+
activity - cognition
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
+
 
creativity - monotony,
+
creativity - monotony
</td>
+
 
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
+
group work - individual work
groupwork - individual work
+
 
</td>
 
</tr>
 
<tr>
 
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
 
 
playfulness - seriousness
 
playfulness - seriousness
</td>
+
 
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
 
 
experience - theory
 
experience - theory
</td>
+
 
<td style="width: 33%; text-align: center;">
 
 
mobility - fixed location
 
mobility - fixed location
</td>
+
</div>
</tr>
+
 
<tr>
 
<td colspan=3>
 
[[File:Methodbalance.png | 400px | center]]
 
</td>
 
</tr>
 
</table>
 
 
So after a phase of playfulness, seriousness helps us to refocus. After a phase of group work, some people enjoy an opportunity for individual  reflection.
 
So after a phase of playfulness, seriousness helps us to refocus. After a phase of group work, some people enjoy an opportunity for individual  reflection.
 +
</div>
  
 
+
<div class=left-box>
<table><tr>
 
<td colspan=2>
 
  
 
===Inhale and Exhale===
 
===Inhale and Exhale===
 
Learning is a balanced circle of a learners activity ("breath out") and a more passive observing/reflecting role ("breath in"). Both need to be balanced and you might mix methods that address active experimentation with those that allow observation and reflection. After active involvement participants need a relaxation phase. After input participants wish often to become active again.  
 
Learning is a balanced circle of a learners activity ("breath out") and a more passive observing/reflecting role ("breath in"). Both need to be balanced and you might mix methods that address active experimentation with those that allow observation and reflection. After active involvement participants need a relaxation phase. After input participants wish often to become active again.  
</td>
+
 
</tr>
+
<table>
 
<tr>
 
<tr>
<td>
+
<td style="width: 50%; border: 0px;">
'''Active Experimentation'''
+
====Action, experimentation====
 
* Games
 
* Games
 
* Discussions
 
* Discussions
 
* Group work
 
* Group work
 
* Changing locations
 
* Changing locations
* ...
+
* Presenting...
 
[[File:Exhale.png | 200px]]
 
[[File:Exhale.png | 200px]]
</td><td>
+
</td>
'''Observation, consumption, reflection'''
+
<td style="width: 50%; border: 0px;">
 +
 
 +
====Observation, consumption, reflection====
 
* Listening to a presentation
 
* Listening to a presentation
 
* Hearing others' opinions
 
* Hearing others' opinions
Line 111: Line 96:
 
* ...
 
* ...
 
[[File:Inhale.png | 200px]]
 
[[File:Inhale.png | 200px]]
</td></tr></table>
+
</td>
 +
</tr>
 +
</table>
 +
</div>
 +
 
 +
<div class=left-box>
  
<table><tr>
 
<td colspan=2>
 
 
===Divergent and Convergent Thinking===
 
===Divergent and Convergent Thinking===
 
[[File: Divergentconvergent.png | 400px | center]]
 
[[File: Divergentconvergent.png | 400px | center]]
</td>
+
<table>
</tr>
 
 
<tr>
 
<tr>
<td style="width: 50%;">
+
<td style="width: 50%; border: 0px;">
'''Divergent Thinking'''
+
====Divergent Thinking====
  
Exploring new and original ideas about a topic and drawing inspiration from the ideas or action of others leads to a colorful bouquet of opportunities. It enables participants to collect material for later reasoning, be mentally open for new experience, gain inspiration
+
Exploring new and original ideas about a topic and drawing inspiration from the ideas or action of others leads to a colorful bouquet of opportunities. It enables participants to collect material for later reasoning, be mentally open for new experience, gain inspiration.
 
</td>
 
</td>
<td>
+
<td style="width: 50%; border: 0px;">
'''Convergent Thinking'''
+
====Convergent Thinking====
 
 
 
To enable learners' creative potential, the learning process should also encompass activities which challenge learners' capacities for convergence - evaluating, selecting, reasoning.  
 
To enable learners' creative potential, the learning process should also encompass activities which challenge learners' capacities for convergence - evaluating, selecting, reasoning.  
 
Evaluate and organize impressions and insights, Follow a goal and finalize processes, Deepen their understanding of a certain topic or process
 
Evaluate and organize impressions and insights, Follow a goal and finalize processes, Deepen their understanding of a certain topic or process
Line 134: Line 120:
 
</tr>
 
</tr>
 
</table>
 
</table>
 +
</div>
  
<table><tr>
+
<div class=left-box>
<td colspan=3>
 
  
===The Whole Personality===
+
===Head-Heart-Hand/Different Competence Dimensions===
Make sure that participants' whole personalities and a diversity of learning preferences are addressed. The goal is that in larger periods of time (half days or days of a training), we use a variety of cognitive, emotional and practical learning.
+
Make sure that participants' whole personalities and a diversity of learning preferences are addressed. The goal is that in larger periods of time (half days or days of a training), we use a variety of cognitive, emotional and practical learning, addressing knowledge, attitude and skills.
</td>
+
 
</tr>
+
<table>
 
<tr>
 
<tr>
 
<td style="width:33%;">
 
<td style="width:33%;">
 
[[File:Cog.png | 110px | center]]
 
[[File:Cog.png | 110px | center]]
'''Cognition'''
+
====Cognition====
 
* Thinking
 
* Thinking
 
*  Judging
 
*  Judging
Line 154: Line 140:
 
</td>
 
</td>
 
<td style="width:33%;">
 
<td style="width:33%;">
  [[File:Emo.png | 110px | center]]
+
  [[File:Emo.png | 100px | center]]
'''Emotion'''
+
====Emotion====
 
* Emotional experiences
 
* Emotional experiences
 
* Visiting groups
 
* Visiting groups
Line 163: Line 149:
 
* ...
 
* ...
 
</td>
 
</td>
 
 
<td style="width:33%;">
 
<td style="width:33%;">
 
[[File:Prac.png | 110px | center]]
 
[[File:Prac.png | 110px | center]]
'''Practice'''
+
====Practice====
* Practice outside the classroom
+
* Practice (includes also practice outside the classroom)
 
* Learning by doing
 
* Learning by doing
 
* Simulation games
 
* Simulation games
Line 175: Line 160:
 
</td>
 
</td>
  
</tr></table>
+
</tr>
 
+
</table>
 +
</div>
 +
<hr class=boldline>
 +
<noinclude>{{:Block: Book: Holistic Learning}}</noinclude>
 +
<hr class=boldline>
 +
<noinclude>{{:Block: Author Elke Heublein}}</noinclude>
 +
<noinclude>{{:Block: Author Nils-Eyk Zimmermann}}</noinclude>
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<div class="methodpage-infos">
 
<div class="methodpage-infos">
 
<hr class=simpleline>
 
<hr class=simpleline>
[[File:Created-by.png  | 20px | Created By ]][[User:Nils.zimmermann | nez]]
+
 
<hr class=simpleline>
 
 
===Related:===
 
===Related:===
*[[Planning]]
+
*[[Before]]
 
<hr class=simpleline>
 
<hr class=simpleline>
 +
 
===Also interesting:===
 
===Also interesting:===
 
*[[Holistic Learning]]
 
*[[Holistic Learning]]

Latest revision as of 15:27, 4 March 2024

Learning preferences vary. Methods that offer variety and provide opportunities for all in the way they are delivered support inspiring and rewarding learning experiences. A good mix and variety also responds to the different phases and dynamics of a learning process.

Check: Addressing Transversal Competences

Methods need to be appropriate for the development of knowledge, skills and attitudes. Check, to what extent the fields of key competences are addressed:


Task-specific factual compe­tence

Do your methods help your participants to:

Identify adequate, knowledge-based solutions for tasks and problems?

Expertise in the specific field or topic of your training...

...and how it relates systematically within its field and to other fields


Methodo­logical compe­tence

Are you offering adequate opportunities for training and conscious, goal-oriented action?

Choosing and implementing methodologies and tools on a justified basis.

Experience with different approaches toward a goal or problem.

Experiential learning in real challenges


Social compe­tence

Can your participants consciously experience their relationship with other people?

Cooperation and teamwork

Constructively dealing with diversity, difference or conflict.


Personal compe­tence/Learning to Learn

Do you leave enough space for your participants to act autonomously,in a self-organized and reflective way?

Addressing learners' self-responsibility and their active involvement of existing competences

Training reflection and assessment skills in regard to own experience, action or opportunities.

Adressing self-organization and learning-to-learn.

Balancing Diverse Needs

A variety of methods in your training can correspond to the diverse needs of your target group. The challenge is to get the attention of all your participants, despite their differing and shifting needs and preferences concerning the methods. Creative and diversified learning arrangements address different senses and stimulate participants’ motivation and attention. For example:

Balance

Methodbalance.png

activity - cognition

creativity - monotony

group work - individual work

playfulness - seriousness

experience - theory

mobility - fixed location

So after a phase of playfulness, seriousness helps us to refocus. After a phase of group work, some people enjoy an opportunity for individual reflection.

Inhale and Exhale

Learning is a balanced circle of a learners activity ("breath out") and a more passive observing/reflecting role ("breath in"). Both need to be balanced and you might mix methods that address active experimentation with those that allow observation and reflection. After active involvement participants need a relaxation phase. After input participants wish often to become active again.

Action, experimentation

  • Games
  • Discussions
  • Group work
  • Changing locations
  • Presenting...

Exhale.png

Observation, consumption, reflection

  • Listening to a presentation
  • Hearing others' opinions
  • Movies
  • Reading
  • Coffee break
  • ...

Inhale.png

Divergent and Convergent Thinking

Divergentconvergent.png

Divergent Thinking

Exploring new and original ideas about a topic and drawing inspiration from the ideas or action of others leads to a colorful bouquet of opportunities. It enables participants to collect material for later reasoning, be mentally open for new experience, gain inspiration.

Convergent Thinking

To enable learners' creative potential, the learning process should also encompass activities which challenge learners' capacities for convergence - evaluating, selecting, reasoning. Evaluate and organize impressions and insights, Follow a goal and finalize processes, Deepen their understanding of a certain topic or process

Head-Heart-Hand/Different Competence Dimensions

Make sure that participants' whole personalities and a diversity of learning preferences are addressed. The goal is that in larger periods of time (half days or days of a training), we use a variety of cognitive, emotional and practical learning, addressing knowledge, attitude and skills.

Cog.png

Cognition

  • Thinking
  • Judging
  • Interpreting
  • Discussions
  • Readings
  • ...
Emo.png

Emotion

  • Emotional experiences
  • Visiting groups
  • Role models
  • Social experience in the group
  • Valuing outcomes
  • ...
Prac.png

Practice

  • Practice (includes also practice outside the classroom)
  • Learning by doing
  • Simulation games
  • Implementing projects
  • Addressing the sense of initiative
  • ...

Handbook for Facilitators: Holistic Learning

Holistic-learning-book-cover.png


E. Heublein (ed.), N. Zimmermann (ed.) (2017). Holistic learning. Planning experiential, inspirational and participatory learning processes. Competendo Handbook for Facilitators.


Skoro.png
Mitost.png
If.png
Erasmusplus.jpg

Elke Heublein

Co-founder of Working Between Cultures. Co-author of Holistic learning. Facilitator since 2004, certified intercultural facilitator (Institute for Intercultural Communikation, LMU München) and trainer (IHK Akademie München/Westerham), adult education (Foundation University Hildesheim). Focus: Cooperation and leadership in heterogenouos teams, higher education, train-the-trainer.

Nils-Eyk Zimmermann

Nils-Eyk Zimmermann

Editor of Competendo. He writes and works on the topics: active citizenship, civil society, digital transformation, non-formal and lifelong learning, capacity building. Coordinator of European projects, in example DIGIT-AL Digital Transformation in Adult Learning for Active Citizenship, DARE network.

Blogs here: Blog: Civil Resilience.
Email: nils.zimmermann@dare-network.eu


Related:


Also interesting:


Our Handbooks Holistic-learning-book-cover.png

E. Heublein, N. Zimmermann

Holistic Learning

Second Handbook for Facilitators: Read more